8/11/24

Gate Check vs. Counter Check: The Ultimate Guide to Traveling with Strollers & Car Seats

Hey there, fellow traveling parent. If you're reading this, you're probably in the thick of planning a trip with your little one, & you've hit that classic parental travel snag: what in the world do you do with the stroller & car seat? Honestly, it can feel like you need a degree in logistics just to get from your front door to the airplane gate.
You've got the bags packed, the snacks ready, & a million "what ifs" running through your mind. The last thing you need is more stress at the airport. So, let's break down one of the biggest questions: should you check your stroller & car seat at the ticket counter, or wheel them all the way to the gate?
Here’s the thing, there’s no single right answer. It really depends on your kid's age, your destination, your gear, & your personal sanity level. I've been there, done that, & have the metaphorical t-shirt. So, let's get into the nitty-gritty of gate checking versus counter checking, so you can make the best choice for your family's next adventure.

The Great Debate: Counter Check vs. Gate Check

First off, let's define our terms. Counter-checking is when you drop off your stroller and/or car seat with your other checked baggage at the airline's ticket counter. You won't see these items again until you land at your destination's baggage claim.
Gate-checking, on the other hand, means you get to use your stroller & transport your car seat all the way through the airport to the gate. Right before you board the plane, you'll fold up your gear, get a special tag from the gate agent, & leave it at the end of the jet bridge. When you deplane, it will be waiting for you in the same spot.
Now, let's break down the pros & cons of each.

Checking at the Ticket Counter: The "Hands-Free" Approach

The biggest appeal of counter-checking is the immediate freedom it offers. You get to the airport, check in, & BAM – you're free of the bulkiest items you'll be traveling with.
The Pros of Counter Checking:
  • Less to Wrangle: Let's be real, navigating a crowded airport is a sport. Doing it with a stroller, a car seat, your carry-ons, & a toddler who wants to run in the opposite direction is an Olympic-level event. Checking your gear at the counter means fewer things to push, pull, & maneuver through security & to the gate.
  • Easier Security Screening: Getting through the TSA checkpoint can be a chaotic dance of taking off shoes, pulling out liquids, & folding up strollers. By checking your big items, you streamline this process significantly.
  • Potentially Less Wear & Tear: This one is debatable, & we'll get into the risks of damage later, but some argue that a well-packaged item checked at the counter might be handled less than one that's gate-checked.
The Cons of Counter Checking:
  • No Wheels in the Terminal: This is the big one. Once you check that stroller, you're on your own. If you have a long walk to the gate, a lengthy layover, or a child who isn't a fan of walking, you'll be carrying them or relying on a baby carrier.
  • The Risk of Damage or Loss: Checked baggage goes on a wild ride through conveyor belts & into the cargo hold. There's always a risk that your expensive car seat or stroller could get damaged or, in a worst-case scenario, lost in transit. Many parents report this as a major concern.
  • Baggage Claim Wait: When you land, you'll have to head to the baggage carousel & wait for your gear to appear. This can be tough after a long flight, especially if your little one is antsy.
Who is Counter Checking Good For?
This option is often best for parents of older toddlers who can walk on their own, or for those who are comfortable using a baby carrier as their primary mode of transport through the airport. It can also be a good choice if you're traveling with multiple adults who can share the load of carrying kids & bags.

Gate Checking: The Convenience King

For many parents, gate-checking is the go-to method. It allows you to keep your wheels right up until the last possible moment, which can be a total lifesaver.
The Pros of Gate Checking:
  • Airport Convenience: Having your stroller in the terminal is a HUGE plus. It's a place for your child to nap, a snack station on wheels, & a carrier for all those little extras you accumulate. This is especially valuable during delays or long layovers.
  • Immediate Access on Arrival: When you get off the plane, your stroller is typically waiting for you right on the jet bridge. This means you can pop your tired kiddo in & cruise to baggage claim or your next connection without having to carry them.
  • Potentially Less Chance of Major Damage: Because gate-checked items are loaded last & unloaded first, some believe they are handled less & are less likely to be crushed under a mountain of suitcases in the cargo hold. However, damage can still occur.
The Cons of Gate Checking:
  • The Security Shuffle: You will have to fold up your stroller to get it through the X-ray machine at the security checkpoint. This can be a bit of a juggling act, especially if you're flying solo.
  • Still a Risk of Damage: While it might be a slightly lower risk than counter-checking, your stroller & car seat are still being handled by baggage crews & exposed to the elements on the tarmac. Scuffs, dirt, & even broken parts are not unheard of.
  • The Gate-Side Scramble: When it's time to board, you'll need to quickly empty your stroller, fold it up, & get it tagged. This can feel a little rushed, especially with a line of people waiting behind you.
Who is Gate Checking Good For?
This is the preferred method for most parents, especially those with infants & younger toddlers. The convenience of having a stroller in the airport often outweighs the minor hassles. If your child is likely to nap in the stroller or you have a long layover, gate-checking is almost always the better choice.

The Car Seat Conundrum: A Whole Different Ball Game

While the counter-check versus gate-check debate for strollers is mostly about convenience, when it comes to car seats, there's a BIG safety element to consider.
The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) & safety experts have a clear stance: the safest place for a child on an airplane is in an approved child restraint system (CRS), not on your lap. Unexpected turbulence can be dangerous, & a parent's arms are not strong enough to hold a child securely.
With that in mind, here are your options for traveling with a car seat:
Option 1: Bring it Onboard (The Safest Choice)
If you've purchased a seat for your child (which is required for kids over two, but recommended for all ages), you can bring your FAA-approved car seat on the plane & install it in their seat.
  • Look for the Label: To be used on a plane, your car seat MUST have a sticker that says, "This restraint is certified for use in motor vehicles and aircraft."
  • The Benefits: This is, without a doubt, the safest way for your child to fly. It also means your car seat is with you the entire time, so there's no risk of it being lost or damaged. Plus, your little one will be in a familiar seat, which might help them sleep better on the flight.
  • The Downside: You have to lug the car seat through the airport, get it through security, & install it on the plane. Some car seats are bulky & heavy, making this a challenging task. There are products like car seat travel belts that can help by attaching the car seat to your rolling carry-on.
Option 2: Gate Check the Car Seat
If you're not bringing the car seat on board (for example, if you have a lap infant), gate-checking is the next best option. This minimizes the time the car seat spends in the hands of baggage handlers & reduces the risk of it getting lost. Many parents feel this is a good compromise between safety & convenience.
Option 3: Counter Check the Car Seat (The Riskiest Choice)
Many car seat safety experts strongly advise against counter-checking a car seat. Here's why:
  • Hidden Damage: You have no idea how the car seat is being handled once it's out of your sight. It could be thrown, dropped, or have heavy luggage piled on top of it. This can cause microfractures or other damage that isn't visible to the naked eye but could compromise the seat's safety in a crash.
  • Airline Liability: Most airlines consider car seats & strollers to be "fragile items" & have a limited release of liability, meaning they may not reimburse you for any damage.
  • No Car Seat at Your Destination: If your car seat is lost or severely damaged, you'll be in a tough spot when you land, especially if you need it to get from the airport to your hotel or rental home.
My two cents on car seats? I ALWAYS recommend buying a seat for your child & bringing the car seat on board. If that's not possible, gate-checking is the only other option I would personally consider. The risk of checking a life-saving device at the counter just isn't worth it to me.

Airline Policies: What You NEED to Know

Here's a crucial tip: ALWAYS check your airline's specific policies before you fly. While most US airlines have similar rules for strollers & car seats, there can be slight variations. Generally, every ticketed passenger (including a lap infant) can check one stroller & one car seat for free.
Here's a quick look at some of the major US airlines' policies as of early 2025 (but again, please double-check before your flight!):
  • American Airlines: Allows one stroller & one car seat per child to be checked for free. You can check them at the counter or the gate. However, large strollers (over 20 lbs) must be checked at the ticket counter.
  • Delta Air Lines: You can check strollers & car seats for free at the curb, ticket counter, or gate.
  • United Airlines: Permits one stroller or foldable wagon & one car seat per child, free of charge. You can check them at the counter or gate. Small, collapsible strollers that fit in the overhead bin can be brought on as a carry-on.
  • Southwest Airlines: Allows one stroller & one car seat per child for free. They can be checked at the counter or the gate. One of the nice things about Southwest is that if you gate-check your items, you can request to have them brought to the jet bridge at your connecting city or final destination.
  • Breeze Airways: One stroller and one car seat per child can be checked for no extra cost at the ticket counter or gate.

To Bag or Not to Bag? The Great Stroller Bag Debate

Another hot topic among traveling parents is whether or not to use a travel bag for your stroller & car seat. These bags can range from simple, lightweight covers to heavy-duty, padded cases.
The Argument FOR Using a Bag:
  • Protection: A good bag can protect your gear from dirt, grease, & moisture on the tarmac. A padded bag can also offer some protection against scratches & dings.
  • Keeps Everything Together: If your stroller has removable parts like cup holders or snack trays, a bag ensures they don't get lost in transit.
  • Easier to Carry: Many car seat bags come with backpack straps, making it much easier to carry the seat through the airport.
  • The "Stuffing" Hack: Let's be honest, many parents (myself included) have been known to stuff a few extra diapers, blankets, or other soft items into a car seat or stroller bag to save space in their luggage. Use this trick at your own risk, as some airlines might not be thrilled about it.
The Argument AGAINST Using a Bag:
  • Another Thing to Carry: A bulky bag is just one more thing to deal with at the airport.
  • The Cost: Good quality, padded travel bags can be expensive.
  • False Sense of Security? Some parents argue that a bag might encourage baggage handlers to be rougher with the item since they can't see what's inside.
  • Hassle at the Gate: Fumbling to get your stroller into a bag while trying to board can be stressful.
The Verdict on Bags:
For a car seat, I'd say a bag is a very good idea, especially if you're gate-checking it. It will at least keep it clean & dry. For a stroller, it's more of a personal preference. If you have an expensive stroller & want to protect it as much as possible, a padded bag is a good investment. If you're traveling with a cheap umbrella stroller, a simple garbage bag might do the trick, or you might choose to go without.

Don't Forget the First Step: Getting to the Airport

Before you even get to the counter vs. gate check debate, you have to physically get all this gear, plus your luggage & your family, to the airport. This can be a major challenge in itself. Driving & parking your own car is often the easiest way to manage all the equipment. But airport parking can be a nightmare of its own – expensive, far from the terminal, & a hassle to navigate.
Here’s where a service like Prked can be a game-changer for traveling families. Instead of dealing with the chaos & cost of official airport lots, Prked connects you with homeowners near the airport who rent out their empty driveways or garages. It's often more affordable & can be much more convenient. Imagine pulling up to a house a few minutes from the airport, easily unloading your mountain of gear, & then grabbing a quick rideshare to the terminal. It takes a HUGE amount of stress out of the very first step of your journey.

My Final Thoughts & Pro-Tips

After countless flights with my own kids, here’s my bottom-line advice:
  1. Safety First with Car Seats: Buy the ticket, take the seat. Bringing your car seat on board is the safest option & the only one that guarantees it won't be lost or damaged. If you can't, gate-check it in a padded bag. I'd avoid counter-checking a car seat at all costs.
  2. Gate-Check Your Stroller: For most families, the convenience of having a stroller in the terminal is simply unbeatable. The small hassle at security & the gate is a small price to pay for a happy, contained child.
  3. Know Before You Go: Check your airline's policies & your car seat's FAA-approval sticker well before your travel day.
  4. Practice Makes Perfect: If you've never folded your travel stroller or put your car seat in its travel bag, do a practice run at home. It will save you a lot of stress at the airport.
  5. Simplify Where You Can: Think about investing in a lightweight, compact travel stroller. It can make a world of difference.
  6. Don't Stress the Small Stuff: Things might not go perfectly. Your stroller might get a scratch. Your kid might have a meltdown. It's all part of the adventure of traveling with a family.
I hope this was helpful as you plan your next trip. Traveling with kids can be a lot of work, but the memories you'll make are SO worth it. Let me know what you think – are you team gate check or counter check? Safe travels
;